Karl Jaspers: The Question of German Guilt Study. Guide. Steven Alan Samson. Liberty University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at. The Question of German Guilt has ratings and 23 reviews. Jon(athan) said: Karl Jaspers examines the question of German guilt associated with the rise. The German as Pariah-Karl Jaspers and the Question of German Guilt. The Guilt Which We Are: An Ontological Approach to Karl Jaspers’ Idea of Guilt.
|Published (Last):||11 January 2015|
|PDF File Size:||18.86 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||15.43 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Read more Read less.
Then he discusses four ways in which a person might try to avoid taking moral responsibility or to mitigate guilt:. Jaspers deals with the guilt, which he dist I had to pick up a book for my philosophy class at university and chose this one, because it was a thin book I got to be honest here and also because it covered a theme I was quite interested in. Kaarl it on Scholar.
Amazon Rapids Fun stories for kids on the go. Buy the selected items together This item: These categories are helpful and the book is a very interesting read, particularly as a historical document, being written so close to the end of the war as it is. For example, he talked about the “zeal to have the other admit guilt”, about “the feeling of guiltlessness” which “holds itself entitled to hold others guilty” I enjoyed the book, I hope you will too.
Jaspers’ dissatisfaction with the popular understanding of mental illness led him to question both the diagnostic criteria and the methods of clinical psychiatry. Political guilt being a fait accompliand criminal guilt being decided by tribunals like the one at Nuremberg, there remains moral and metaphysical guilt, which each German must deal with individually or in a spirit of humble cooperation with each other.
The emphasis was not so much on the assessment of past crimes, or about deciding the just retribution, than about transforming the unique situation as an opportunity of fundamental inner-renewal of the Germans.
He was among the first to acquaint German readers with the works of Kierkegaard.
This book was written not long after the end of WW2, but is still considered a classic guily the ‘s of books on the German psyche of the first half of the 20th c. A European Review 16 3: Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Jaspers had to resign from his post in After World War I he became Professor of Philosophy at Heidelberg, where he achieved fame as a brilliant teacher and an early exponent of existentialism.
The question of German guilt
The idea behind is that discourse helps heal the trauma; it was precisely lack of communication that was the most enduring legacy of the war. He listed four categories of guilt: This, as he says, was “a common inspiring task – of not being Germans as we happen to be, but becoming German as we are not yet but ought to be, and as we hear it in the call of our ancestors rather than in the history of national idols.
This is a kind of feeling of co-responsibility for simply being human. Alexa Actionable Analytics for the Web. Share your thoughts with other customers.
The Question of German Guilt – Karl Jaspers – Google Books
ghe To wait until justice is done by whoever else, or to blame the allies so as to alleviate one’s own moral burden, or worse to claim to have always been revolting despite every sign of obedience- there were symptoms of a generation that had been suffering under a totalitarian power. By now, the dream of an international order of states in which impartial law makes the rule of force obsolete should seem almost as silly as the utopian communism that shared its century.
Jaspers points out that even Churchill wrote in positive terms about Hitler in the 30s, even though, according to Jaspers, it was obvious from the start what Hitler was up to.
Whilst not broaching new ideas, this article introduced a new method of study. An Introduction to Philosophy.
Karl Jaspers’s “The Question of German Guilt”
There are several elements in this renewal. Picked up an early English version, started reading it and, I could not put it down until I was done. Jan 23, Nikolina Matijevic rated it it was amazing.
Top Reviews Most recent Top Reviews. Jun 09, David Gross rated it really liked it Shelves: Customers who bought this item also guily. Margaret Gilbert – – The Journal of Ethics 6 2: This small book is obviously an occasional work, prompted by the uneasy relationship between Jasspers and the rest of the world after the War. Jaspers’s unblemished record as an anti-Nazi as well as his sentient mind, made him a rallying point for those of his compatriots who wished to reconstruct a free and democratic Germany.
After World War I he became Professor of Philosophy at Heidelberg, where he achieved fame as a brilliant teacher and an early exponent of existentialism.
His brand of dishonesty, at least that portion that has been well-documented by the University of Colorado investigative committee, would be considered par-for-the-course or probably insufficiently disingenuous if his career was as a politician or pundit, but hurrah to the University for holding him to a higher standard.
Karl Jaspers’s “The Question of German Guilt” • TPL
However, this might also include other European nations. From the total isolation into which the Hitler regiem forced him, Jasper returned in to a position of central intellectual leadership of the younger liberal elements of Germany. If a German manages to get past these and other such tempting excuses, he will morally judge himself and quite possibly find himself morally guilty to add to the political guilt he shares. This is because the myth of American Exceptionalism must be preserved, and thus the US has never made I found this timely and moving, though it was written in Issues of collective guilt and collective punishment also come into play in defenses of the U.
However, I was a little disappointed that there was not more discussion and problematization on the different types of guilt. Laing and Richard Bentall have criticised it, stressing that taking this stance can lead therapists into the complacency of assuming that because they do not understand a patient, the patient is deluded and further investigation on the part of the therapist will have no effect.
Consequences of American Conquest and Carnage adopts and amends this schema to arrive at his own conclusions about the guilt of USians. Gilbert Harman – – Oxford Studies in Metaethics 4: Differentiation of German Guilt. This is directly opposed to vengence, which “keep[s] reacting quextion every quuestion with a counterattack” The Perennial Scope of Philosophy. No trivia or quizzes yet. The Picket Line 4 November